History of Town Supervisors
| Teunis A. VanSlyke | 1811 - 1813,1817,1824 |
| Conrad Houghtaling | 1814, 1821 - 1823 |
| Anthony VanBergen | 1815 - 1816, 1818 - 1820 |
| Gilbert Bedell | 1825 - 1831, 1834 - 1835 |
| Anthony C. Houghtaling | 1832 - 1833 |
| Thomas C. Houghtaling | 1836 - 1837, 1839 |
| Jonathan Miller | 1838, 1840 |
| Thomas Bedell | 1841 - 1842 |
| Lewis Crandell | 1843 - 1844 |
| Jesse Greene | 1845 - 1846 |
| Matthew Youmans | 1847 |
| Gerry Coonly | 1848 - 1849 |
| Edward E. Sherman | 1850 |
| Amos Houghtaling | 1851 - 1852 |
| Nathaniel O. Palmer | 1853 - 1854 |
| Henry A. Whitbeck | 1855 - 1857 |
| John G. Raymond | 1858 - 1859 |
| Peter Stover | 1860 - 1861 |
| Edgar Halstead | 1862 - 1863 |
| David S. Miller | 1864 - 1865 |
| Jedediah R. Baldwin | 1866 - 1867 |
| William W. Wheeler | 1868 - 1869 |
| Jeremiah Dean | 1870 - 1871 |
| Benjamin B. Hotaling | 1872 - 1873 |
| Warren Smith | 1874 - 1875 |
| Henry Harden | 1876 |
| Augustus Sherman | 1877 - 1878 |
| Joseph A. Losee | 1879 |
| John Colvin | 1880 - 1881 |
| Peter R. Cary | 1882 - 1883 |
| John W. Stover | 1884 - 1885 |
| Newton Sweet | 1886 |
| Henry VanBergen | 1887 - 1888 |
| Jasper K. Hotaling | 1889 - 1891 |
| William C. Harden | 1892 - 1893 |
| Charles W. Mackey | 1894 - 1899 |
| Cornelius V. Elmendorf | 1900 - 1903 |
| Bronk VanSlyke | 1904 - 1907 |
| Ezra H. Palmer | 1908 - 1909 |
| Henry J. Miller | 1910 - 1913 |
| Dale S. Baldwin | 1914 - 1918; 1936 - 1941 |
| Edwin C. VanderPoel | 1918 - 1919 |
| Orville G. Hotaling | 1920 - 1925 |
| Levitt C. Powell | 1926 - 1933 |
| Oscar E. Yeomans | 1934 - 1935 |
| Cecil C. Hallock | 1942 - 1961 |
| Clare A. Robbins | 1962 - 1967 |
| Clifton S. Baldwin | 1968 - 1969 |
| William Finke, Jr. | 1970 - 1971 |
| Nils Backlund | 1972 - 1981 |
| Robert C. Hallock | 1982 - 1984 |
| Sal Costanza | 1985 - 1986 |
| Donald McBride | 1987 |
| Gordon Kliese | 1988 |
| Eleanor Shafer | 1988 - 1990 |
| Robert C. Hallock (Acting) | 1990 |
| David Louis | 1990 - 1993 |
| Edward P. Barber | 1994 - 1999 |
| Warren Curtis | 2000 - 2001 |
| David Louis | 2002 - 2009 |
|
Susan O'Rorke Nick Dellisanti |
2010 - 2014 2014- |